There’s a rule for that: the customer is always right (when it comes to things crashing and exploding)

It’s always fun to try and identify game rules that came into existence not because they were part of the designers’ vision, but because players insisted on them.

When you’re a game designer faced with player demands for a rule you don’t particularly want to include in the game, you have a few choices. You can simply ignore the requests. Alternately, you could include a passive-aggressive note in the rulebook:

No need to get snippy about it!

That’s from the Star Fleet Battles Master Rulebook, and it makes me smile every time I read it. In defense of the players crying out to the heavens for such a rule, ships ramming into each other does sometimes happen in Star Trek, most memorably in Star Trek: Nemesis; and besides, who wouldn’t want a chance to melodramatically shout “RAMMING SPEED!!!” during the ever-suspenseful SPEED DETERMINATION PHASE of a Star Fleet Battles match?

Nevertheless I can sympathize with the designers’ annoyance here: if it were possible to ram other ships in Star Fleet Battles, every single battle would end with the losing player attempting to ram the other player out of spite, and players would start fielding ships not for their tactical value, but to use as kamikazes. That might be fun for a match or two, but would quickly get old, and doesn’t really seem like the kind of thing the Federation would do.

But there’s another way designers can react to unreasonable player requests: just roll with it. From Tactical Operations, a book of optional advanced rules for Battletech:

Bless you, Battletech rule designers.

In a regular Battletech game, landing hits on a ‘Mech’s nuclear-powered engine can quickly disable the ‘Mech, but won’t result in the Hollywood-style atomic explosion that players have long pined for. But this is the best way to do it: make it an optional rule.

(In this case, the Battletech designers must accept some blame for this rule, because ‘Mech fusion engines exploding is a thing that has happened from time to time in Battletech novels. And the intro videos to the third and fifth installments of the Mechwarrior videogames feature ‘Mechs detonating in big nuclear fireballs when their engines take critical damage. There’s just something about ‘Mech reactors going critical that we can’t get enough of!)

I am sure that most complex games that aim for quasi-realism run into this sort of thing a lot: the tension between sticking to the purity of your vision for the game, and giving players what they want. Know of any other good examples?

Facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedinmailby feather

6 Comments

  1. Monty says:

    WOW just what I was searching for. Came here by searching for Cara Meningkatkan Rasio Kemenangan Taruhan Mix Parlay

  2. Diane says:

    With havin so much content do you ever run into any issues of plagorism or copyright violation? My website has a lot
    of unique content I’ve either authored myself or outsourced but it appears a lot of it is popping it up all over the web without my
    permission. Do you know any methods to help prevent content from being
    ripped off? I’d really appreciate it.

  3. Jonelle says:

    Hello to every , for the reason that I am in fact keen of
    reading this website’s post to be updated daily.
    It carries pleasant stuff.

  4. fleshlight toy
    We all know the story of struggling to access adult content as young adults (or
    older shy adults) mustering up the guts to ask
    for a behind the counter magazine or slip into a toyshop.
    It was even harder for those with niche interests. (If it was hard
    to buy a straight up traditional porn DVD, it was even harder to ask
    whether there were any latex fetish videos in the back.) You might have found something fringe
    y in an “adult catalog,” if you were lucky enough to figure out how the heck to get those sent to your house (and didn’t mind the “discreet”
    but actually extremely obvious plain brown wrapper showing up on your
    kitchen table)..

    fleshlight masturbation Then she learned that with
    a dildo (glass, steel or silicone) inside while using a clit vibe made her orgasms
    much stronger. As she explained it she likes something to squeezeThe only non vibrating toy to
    bring to orgasm is the Pure Wand. The unique curved shape
    makes manipulating it quite easyGraduate school of penetration recently we
    started adding anal penetration creating even more pressure and bigger orgasms!.
    fleshlight masturbation

    fleshlight masturbation Hey I know tht I really shouldnt complain, n tht complainin about my
    boobs isn’t goin to help much, bcoz theres nuthin I can do about it.
    I get where ur cumin from with the whole ‘eyes n hair’ thing, its just degrading when you think someone really deeply cares about u, only to find out
    a couple days later theyre only in it because they think that theyre gunna get sum
    from the chik with big boobs. I know complainin is useless, n thts
    y i dnt tell my frends or anyone else really about the issues i got with myself n the way im percieved, i put the way i
    feel out on this thingy to try n work it all out, but its kinda confused me
    even more lol. fleshlight masturbation

    best fleshlight In the before, school shootings were something that we didn’t have to think about too much.
    They were one of those things that had to be covered in the
    pre year staff onboarding: Here is the procedure if your student requires an Epi pen; here is what to do if
    there’s a fight in your classroom; oh, and on Page 27, please review the procedure for lockdown drills.
    Mass shootings were few and far between.. best fleshlight

    fleshlight masturbation Police said the correctional officer called
    for emergency assistance. A CBF correctional lieutenant, a correctional officer, and
    a Howard County police officer responded. The correctional lieutenant and police officer performed CPR until Howard County Fire
    and Rescue EMS arrived. What’s the big deal? Apple
    shaved $50 off its standard battery fee in an extraordinary but limited time effort to get back in our
    good graces. It got caught in December slowing iPhones with worn out batteries a move, it says, that keeps
    the phones from unexpectedly shutting down. If you always suspected your old iPhone was getting slower, you were right..
    fleshlight masturbation

    best fleshlight Be civil, and try to maintain an even tone.
    We all human beings on the other side of the screen. We can call this
    the human decency rule.Don respond to someone opening up about having a
    DB with the assumption that they their deadbedroom (“Your husband won fuck you cuz you ugly, right?” “Your wife doesn want you because you aren any good in bed!”).
    This high quality pump comes with three cylinders of
    different sizes, in order to get the perfect fit for each woman’s body and to offer a range of
    sensations. Blood flow to the genital organs plays a key role in female arousal, and can increase natural lubrication and
    make it easier to reach orgasm. The pump’s suction effect can make the
    clitoris much more sensitive to the slightest caress or stimulation..
    best fleshlight

    fleshlight sale “The good news is that Facebook is gaining more and better detection of Russian influence operations,”
    said Clint Watts, a disinformation expert and senior
    fellow at the Center for Cyber and Homeland Security at George Washington University.
    “The bad news is this shows that Russia is still conducting influence operations on social media, hurting their platforms. It will be a persistent problem now and in the future, not one limited to the presidential election of 2016.”.
    fleshlight sale

    male fleshlight Rhythm NATYA by Kama Sutra is a luxury vibrator, specially made
    for enjoying together as a couple. Its flexible and adjustable design can be folded to fit your anatomy and provide the best kind of stimulation. This sex toy is
    efficient, waterproof and comes with a wireless remote control,
    which also vibrates!. That is why I find it difficult to understand women’s emotions.
    Their behaivors and how they are really really feeling inside.
    Well, there’s often a lot of pressure on women to be smiley and
    nice all the time and not offend anyone, especially
    men male fleshlight.

  5. 7717Yx.Com says:

    7717Yx.Com

    The Staging Point » Blog Archive » There’s a rule for that: the customer is always right (when it comes to things crashing and exploding)

  6. Hair Extensions

    The Staging Point » Blog Archive » There’s a rule for that: the customer is always right (when it comes to things crashing and exploding)

Leave a Reply